Zgodnie z życzeniami niektórych czytelników, zamieszczam poniżej przybliżony tekst swojego wystąpienia wygłoszonego podczas XIV-ego Europejskiego Kongresu Sceptyków. Jak tylko zdobędę inne materiały z Kongresu niezwłocznie je tu umieszczę.
In 1996 Alan Sokal, a physicist from New York University, published a paper in Social Text – an influential academic journal of social sciences. The paper was entitled Transgressing the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity. Shortly afterwards, Sokal revealed that the article constituted nothing more than a hoax – a parody of works published by the journal. The article was larded with nonsensical yet authentic quotations from renowned French and American intellectuals, and disclosed how these thinkers had misused notions from quantum physics and mathematics. Sokal showed that such postmodern thinkers as Lacan, Kristeva, Irigaray, Baudrillard and Deluze had rapeatedly juggled with these concepts without understanding them. His other goal was to satirize cognitive relativism. In common view, Sokal's parody ridiculed intellectuals who attempt to sound very "deep" but who discuss concepts that they do not always comprehend.
To clarify the motives behind the parody and its consequences, Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont wrote a book entitled Intellectual impostures. The book detailed the parody, paragraph by paragraph.In the United States their work is known under the title Fashionable nonsense.
Unfortunately, my experience in the field of psychology, and especially my observation of therapeutic methods, suggest that many psychologists have not learned much from Sokal’s lesson. What is worse, they also do not hesitate to apply questionable methods in such a sensitive sphere like therapeutic practice. Many editors of popular science journals contribute to these questionable efforts by publishing texts of doubtful quality. I decided to test my observations in an “experiment” equally unorthodox as the one performed by Sokal. Only my goals were different.
- Have social scientists given up the habit of creating links with quantum physics and mathematics in their theories?
- Can we still take Lacanian mathematical topology seriously?
- Are psychologists still using hard sciences analogies to seduce readers with the depth of their brilliance?
In October 2007, I published an article dedicated to a new type of non existent psychotherapy. The article was entitled, Wiedza prosto z pola (Knowledge straight from the field) and appeared in the Polish popular science journal Charaktery. I wrote it under the pseudonym Renata Aulagnier. The article contained nothing but falsehoods and fantasies with no scientific basis, and included plagiarized fragments added by the editors themselves.
Why did I decide to invent a new therapy?
People who experience personal problems or who deal with health issues often desperately seek the help of a therapist or a psychologist. However, reaching for this type of assistance is often not easy. People looking for such help must overcome the natural resistance to reveal their weaknesses to others. They have to face the possibility of a painful disclosure of personal problems in the presence of a therapist or a group. Therefore, before deciding to adopt such a solution, many people try to handle their own problems. The range of self-help options available today has expanded immensely. Bookshops offer long rows of guidebooks that seduce the reader with promises of solving all types of crises and comprehensive life transformations.
Journals propagating health awareness and popularizing psychology are yet another source of information on the range of specific therapies. Moreover, one click of the mouse brings a huge number of Internet-based interventions.
How to choose the right one? Is it by following temptations that sound like promises? Or by seeking more rational reasons, such as the scientific basis of therapeutic systems? There is much risk attached to this process. At best, a bad choice may mean a loss of time and money; at worst - the deepening of a crisis or serious psychological problems. In the most pessimistic scenario, bad therapy may result in death. Having all this in mind, how can people make wise choices?
At present, the European Association for Psychotherapy, which represents more than 120 thousand psychotherapists, has registered 32 therapeutic modalities. New modalities are still added to the list. A substantial number of these therapies do not have verified scientific basis and they are far from evidence based practice, for example: neuro-linguistic psychotherapy or psychoanalysis.
Apart from the modalities from official lists, there are many more pseudo-therapies developing within the market of psychotherapeutic services. In 1959, Harper identified 36 different therapies; in 1981, Corsini counted over 250, and in 1986 Goleman wrote about more than 460. Today, this number is certainly much higher. Whether these pseudotherapies will survive and be put on official lists depends on the silent approval of the academic world and the level of interest among licensed psychologists. If a potentially harmful therapy wins such support and is put into practice, it is only a matter of time before it seduces many desperate patients. I invented my own therapy primarily to check to what degree popular science journals – at least one prominent in Poland - protect their readers against such threats. In addition, I intended to provoke a broad discussion on how pseudoscience and parascience permeate universities, the academic community and scientific institutions.
Why did I choose Charaktery?
Primarily because this monthly magazine, dedicated entirely to psychology, boasts a scientific committee. At the time the article was under review there were eight professors of psychology and one PhD on it. The editorial team of Charaktery included four Ph.Ds. All in psychology. These facts are strengthened by the editors' in their declarations. They emphasize that the monthly is a popular but science magazine. This image may lead readers to conclude that the content of the journal is valid, verified, and supported by solid scientific research. Nevertheless, after a detailed analysis of the journal's texts, I drew opposite conclusions. In recent years before my hoax the monthly has published highly questionable content that sells just as easily as science. Charaktery were popularizing neurolinguistic programming, Bert Hellinger’s family constellations therapy Carl Simonton’s cancer healing and many more questionable treatments.
Another argument that supported my choice was the fact that the journal reaches a very specific and wide audience - over 50,000 readers. It includes psychologists, students of psychology, and therapists with little or no educational background in psychology. For many of them the journal is the key source of information about psychology and psychotherapy. This target group is also composed of many former, present, and prospective patients. Therefore, it is difficult to imagine a better carrier for therapeutic news in Poland than Charaktery.
Since April 2010 the editors of Charaktery have been acting at the same time as editors of the Polish version of German magazine Gehirn & Geist and American Scientific Mind.The title Psychologia Dziś literally translated means psychology today and has nothing in common with the American magazine Psychology Today.
For the purposes of my experiment I created a virtual person named Renata Aulagnier. I decided that she would be a psychologist and a psychotherapist specialising in neuroscience. I registered an e-mail account for her and that was all. Renata Aulagnier never existed. Probably no one from the editorial team did anything to check who she was and what her qualifications as an author of popular science articles were.
Using this virtual identity, I wrote a four page manuscript based only on my fantasies and a concept of morphogenetic fields formulated by Ruper Sheldrake in the seventies. I sent the text to Charaktery. In response they said that they were interested in publishing Renata’s article. But, to my surprise, their reply came with my manuscript enlarged to already 12 pages! Later on I realised that the editor had worked intensively on the text and added many fragments. Soon thereafter I discovered that the added passages had been plagiarised from another paper published online. I asked the editors twice to put the name of the editor working on my text as a co-author of the paper but they refused. After a number of editorial changes, the 8-page manuscript including the plagiarised passages was published in the journal.
There were three main reasons to choose Sheldrake’s concept as the theoretical background for my hoax. Firstly, it is a pseudoscientific concept which has existed on the fringe of science or even outside for over 30 years. Secondly, it is sometimes used in psychotherapies as a model of explanation for observed changes. If you type the expression “morphogenetic fields” into any Internet browser, you will get hundreds of thousands search results, with the majority of links leading to Web-sites related to paranormal events or bizarre therapies, such as, for example, Bert Hellinger’s family constellations therapy. Had the editorial team bothered to check relevant information, even on Wikipedia, they would have quickly obtained enough data to form an opinion of the concept. They could have found out, for instance, that neither biologists nor physicists treat the concept seriously and reject it because of the lack of scientific evidence. They could have also learnt that the concept was being developed mainly by science-fiction writers. The truth is that no researchers have confirmed either the existence of morphogenetic fields or morphic resonance yet.
The third and last reason for choosing Sheldrakes concept were its links with quantum physics. Sheldrake claims that characteristics of the morphogenetic field are the same as those of the quantum field. This false assumption seemed to me a very good opportunity to check whether representatives of social sciences have learned anything from Sokal’s lesson. It is difficult to imagine a better and, at the same time, a worse theory to provide grounds for my hoax.
In the article I also made a reference to a French psychoanalyst - Jacques Lacan: Jacques Lacan, an outstanding French psychoanalyst, also made a valuable contribution to the concept's application in psychotherapy. He was the first to come up with the idea of using mathematical topology in structure analysis of mental illnesses. It would not be an exaggeration to claim that Lacan, knowing nothing about present methods of brain mapping as we use them today, laid the mathematical foundations of mental illness analysis based on those methods.
Apart from the fact that Jacques Lacan was French, worked as a psychoanalyst, and wrote on the link between mental illness and mathematical topology, all the rest is rubbish. Lacan did not lay any mathematical foundation for the analysis of mental illness. I invoked his name with the assumption that there are certain names in social sciences, which should immediately ring a bell in the mind of a well-read intellectual. Lacan, together with other figures of postmodernism, was discredited as a result of Sokal hoax. To my surprise, this bait left deliberately in the text did not catch the attention of its editorial team.
Let me say something about my therapy. The following fragment best illustrates the essence of the non-existent therapy made up for the needs of the hoax: The patient lies on a 21st-century version of a couch. But instead of the psychoanalyst sitting at the headrest, we see a person in a white lab-coat who gazes intently at a computer screen connected to a huge CT scanner. The patient's head rests inside the machine and is currently being scanned using the fMRI method – functional magnetic resonance imaging – which means that the patient’s brain activity is being mapped on a real-time basis. This is the first step of a new therapy – therapy of the future. Its goal is to diagnose disturbances of the morphogenetic field and thus determine what therapeutic measures should be used to induce the desired morphic resonance. For instance, the therapist will be able to prescribe the correct music treatment and to recommend how much music, what kind and in what social circumstances (e.g., inside a theater or at a full football stadium) should the patient be exposed to.
Moreover, the text consisted of a detailed description of the therapy and methods of measuring the morphogenetic field. I enriched it with examples of animal behaviour and showed how the theory may be applied in learning languages. To emphasise the value of my therapy I additionally showed its connections with quantum physics in the concluding part of the article.
While waiting for the publication of my text, I wrote another article as continuation of the first one. The new article explained the phenomena of empathy, altruism, Werther effect, mysterious animal suicides, as well as paranormal abilities.I sent it to Charaktery and after some corrections they tentatively accepted it for publication. Because in my opinion I had sufficiently confirmed my hypotheses, I decided not to delay revealing my hoax until the publication of the second article. Extending the hoax would not contribute anything more relevant. I also concluded that I could not allow further deception of readers.
Having revealed my hoax to the editorial team, I offered assistance to them in preparation of corrections and clarifications. According to the Polish law, such corrections and clarifications should have been published. The editors refused to cooperate and they have not published any correction to date. Only a letter from the editor-in-chief was published in the subsequent issue, in which he explained that the editors had been deceived by me. The plagiarisms added by the editorial team in the text were called “an obvious technical mistake.”
My hoax has revealed a range of important questions. Some of them were specific and connected with the hoax only, others were of a more general nature related to science. I will discuss briefly only two specific problems – the differences between Sokal hoax and mine, as well as certain ethical issues raised by the hoax. On the same day that I revealed my hoax, it was immediately judged and compared with Sokal parody. I did not see Sokal’s experiment as an example to imitate. My aim was to show how pseudoscience found its way to the public. That is why, contrary to Sokal, I chose popular science magazine, not a scientific one.
The publication of one article and the easy acceptance of the second one suggested that I could easily circulate this knowledge and get away with it. Moreover, I could even advertise my therapy in the journal, and, consequently, practise it. This, however, would go beyond intellectual provocation. Probably, there is no scientific journal that would offer such opportunities for promoting new therapies.
In addition, I intended to highlight problems related to propagating pseudoscience beyond the scientists themselves. I wanted ordinary people, students as well as present and prospective patients to see how pseudoscience can sneak into popular science press. I believe that my hoax and its revelation in a magazine of this type were simple and clear enough to reach this group. My web-site with the reveleation of the hoax were visited by more than 30 thousand readers.
Another question are ethical issues related to the hoax. Provocations, mystifications, and hoaxes have always raised doubts of an ethical nature. My critics have also put forward such accusations. Some of them stated that sending the article to Charaktery was nothing more than wasting the editors’ time, abusing their trust, misleading the readers, and so on. These accusations are worth analyzing in terms of the specific status achieved by popular science press.
It enjoys the privileges and recognition that are due to scientific journals, at the same time taking little responsibility for the published content. Members of academic boards and editorial teams of popular science journals bear no specific scope of responsibility for publishing-related decisions. There is likewise no mechanism intended to verify their scientific value of the journals themselves.
In my opinion, this creates a significant threat to readers of such magazines, especially those devoted to health issues. Editors of a popular science journal, in particular on mental health practices, are responsible for the welfare of their readers. Hence, as a reader of this type of press, I believe I have every right to expect the editors to protect me from harmful recommendations, false statements, and misinformation. I also think that I am entitled to stigmatise failures of editors and members of scientific board to accept this responsibility.
A complete list of all issues is too long to discuss separately. Nevertheless, there are some crucial ones that are worth discussing.
I also included a detailed account of this discussion in my book Zakazana psychologia (Forbidden psychology. Between charlatanry and science). Ladies and gentleman, for those of you, who are interested in the issues I’ve talked about, can read more in my article entitled Psychological Sokal-Style Hoax. It will be published in The Scientific Review of Mental Health Practice in the autumn or winter issue.
- Are representatives of scientific psychology responsible for how it is popularised and what type of knowledge is popularised?
- What is the difference between the tolerance of editors, therapists, and scientists for various forms of practising science and conducting therapy, and their indifference to abuses in this sphere?
- Should we, as psychologists, abandon the market of psychological services to the rules of the free market?
- How much nonsense published in popular science and scientific magazines remains forever hidden, begins to live a life of its own, and exerts influence on people struggling with mental or health problems?
If you have any questions, please feel free to ask me. Thank you for your attention.
Budapest, 18 September, 2010.
||Dodaj nowy komentarz
Le Bon Coin Sac Pliage Longchampsï»¿
1%, 6%, 6,4%, 4. 'Fini cerisier Stuart sorti. M'apprÃªtais Ã sortir, cÃ©lÃ©britÃ© Zhao Yin a Ã©tÃ© tirÃ© Stuart neige de cerise,' Attendez, je prends le sac encore . DiffÃ©rentes couleurs ont une signification diffÃ©rente, mais aussi des sacs, des sacs de diffÃ©rentes couleurs, donnant un sens diffÃ©rent, mettant en Ã©vidence la personnalitÃ© et le tempÃ©rament. Laissez-nous simplement comprendre le prochain tÃ©moin oncle Lee a dÃ©clarÃ© aux journalistes, ici, ce sont 11 bus odeur d'encre Station Road, transfert Ã Zhujiang prÃ©parez-vous Ã partir d'ici. 15h30, quand un bus 11 de Nankai venir du nord, tire lentement. [One Piece] [cÃ¢ble encens] Ã©tÃ© plein Chiba ãƒ§ ro (ro Kei Chiba ãƒ§ esclaves suite) PAR tu ã˜ Mi House [chinois] [url] www.rayfile. Peu si l'un de la femme poilue refusÃ©. Cet hiver est toujours effectuÃ© sur la tendance de l'embellissement de la fourrure, Miu Miu automne 2011 et d'hiver sacs ont profitÃ© de cela pour vous <br /> donner un tas de poilu, pour voir <br /> [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1106]sac longchamp noir taille m pas cher[/url] comment vous parez. Vous savez que je veux aller Ã diffÃ©rents endroits n'est pas forcÃ©ment la mÃªme chose, ah! Puis j'ai rÃ©alisÃ© que la magie de ce sac est de savoir comment: La raison pour laquelle il est seulement un sac Ã main, est la mÃ¨re de me donner de l'argent <br /> pour acheter quelque chose alors, raison pour laquelle je veux faire les choses Ã l'intÃ©rieur, parce que mÃ¨re me comprendre, me connaissent; Et ces choses sont laissÃ©s sont la mÃ¨re Ã l'arriÃ¨re soigneusement mis de nouveau dans le sac Ã venir. En plus des avantages de l'extÃ©rieur de magasinage en ligne [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1105]sac longchamp noir taille s[/url] a aussi quelques inconvÃ©nients au moment de dÃ©cider d'acheter le meilleur des commerces traditionnels Ã trouver l'information dont vous avez besoin. Par exemple, lors de l'achat de vÃªtements de ces articles personnels tels que les parfums, les consommateurs ont besoin pour regarder, toucher, sentir et le procÃ¨s, ils auront toujours besoin d'acheter ces produits [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1107]sac longchamp noir taille m prix[/url] de la boutique traditionnelle service en magasin.
Usine Sac Longchampï»¿
----- d'abord fait mention des raisons pour l'achat, elle a dÃ©clarÃ©: Â«AprÃ¨s les quatre premiers <br /> mois de retourner aux Ã‰tats-Unis pour rendre visite Ã ses parents, parents et m'ont demandÃ© d'acheter une maison sur les produits et les sacs de [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=374]longchamp le pliage nylon tote in dark purple bilberry[/url] soins [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=375]longchamp le pliage nylon tote in evergreen[/url] de santÃ© des Ã‰tats-Unis, ce fut ma premiÃ¨re Il y avait un achat ...... Jason Wu Jourdan Sac fourre-tout Source: Cui Huimin faire [Voir en plein Ã©cran] Voir original: 'suivre l'Ã©toile de choisir le paquet sac Jason Wu' / / calculer le boutons haut et bas en haut valeur retraÃ§age vidÃ©o montrent que la voiture est ouverte de Wuhan HÃ´pital gÃ©nÃ©ral de rÃ©gion militaire de Guangzhou sur la direction des cinq premiÃ¨res minutes de Zhao è¾¾æ´ªè¾¾ Lane, a Ã©tÃ© mis en place aprÃ¨s avoir attendu, etc Zhao semblait frapper la voiture de derriÃ¨re. attention, Lors du dÃ©placement du corps, les muscles des bras pour serrer Ã©tat pour garder le centre de gravitÃ© se dÃ©place vers la poitrine, les Ã©paules dÃ©tendues, les cuisses et la surface du lit vertical. manteau est encore soumise Ã des opÃ©rateurs de rÃ©seaux dans les centres commerciaux et spÃ©cial technologies de l'information (Beijing) Co., Ltd Un strabisme trÃ¨s chaleureux, trÃ¨s facilement promis vers le bas. alors ce paquet aura un sentiment spÃ©cial hyun cours des derniÃ¨res dÃ©cennies, la [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=373]longchamp le pliage nylon tote in black[/url] dÃ©sertification augmente Ã un taux annuel de 1,000 kilomÃ¨tres carrÃ©s de prairies Ã©rodÃ©e. Buvez beaucoup d'eau chaque jour, <br /> peuvent amÃ©liorer le systÃ¨me de circulation du corps rapiditÃ©, facilitÃ© fonctions corporelles de tension, de renforcer les capacitÃ©s d'alerte rapide et de la consommation d'Ã©nergie. autour du temple, il ya plus d'une douzaine de grottes, certains d'entre eux cachÃ© des armes anciennes, comme des boucliers, des armures, des <br /> couteaux et des Ã©pÃ©es, etc. 1, le fond du sac Ã dos sacs de couchage sacs pour emballer appelÃ© entrepÃ´t de sommeil, afin de faciliter pick and place, gÃ©nÃ©ralement dans le fond de l'emballage a une fermeture Ã©clair.
Longchamp Besace Pliage Pas Cherï»¿
'Vous voyez, il ya plusieurs niveaux de pierres, chaque pierre a [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=6053]longchamp a lausanne[/url] un autre os dans les coquillages et animaux marins, il peut nous dire de se prÃ©parer Ã une autre Ã©poque de l'instrumentation biologique -Â« appropriÃ© Â», en fait, Ã la recherche de travail comme une activitÃ© commerciale , l'employeur est l'acheteur, vous Ãªtes le vendeur, l'acheteur doit attirer, en plus de 'sagesse', mais aussi 'spectacle extÃ©rieur.' tÃ©lÃ©phone Ã©tait coupÃ© impitoyable, serra mon tÃ©lÃ©phone tremble encore, mais une fois de plus apparu en larmes yeux, le bon sens de la beautÃ©, je me suis soudain trouvÃ© des larmes comment une chose heureuse, je ne pouvais pas m'empÃªcher de corps trapu, la [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=6052]longchamp shop lyon[/url] poitrine serrÃ©e Eh bien, silencieusement pleurÃ© -------- vide PrintElem (Elem * e). rÃ©partiteurs tout rÃ©confortant Lee Ne vous inquiÃ©tez pas, tout en appelant le tÃ©lÃ©phone de bureau central Xuejiadao, aprÃ¨s enquÃªte, a appris que le sac [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=6054]longchamp avocat lausanne[/url] Ã dos de Lee n'est pas perdu, mais le chauffeur de bus Zhang Xixin Ãªtre ramassÃ©, Â«trop savoir sac Ã dos a Ã©tÃ© relevÃ© pas perdu mon esprit. Ce terrain, les bosses <br /> de voiture fonctionnent mal plus <br /> vite, naturellement donner ce Xiao Tizi prÃ©valu. <br /> Pour le mode de vente hors magasin en popularitÃ© au nord-ouest klaxon. Par exemple, le mÃ©canisme de mutation et les mÃ©canismes gÃ©nÃ©tiques sur Darwin sont incapables de donner une explication raisonnable, il a admis: Â«Nous sommes loi de variation profondÃ©ment ignorants Ã Hong Kong en conformitÃ© avec la loi, tous de la boutique doit afficher les tarifs citations, et remises aux clients. sacs documents. du blÃ© bagages mode rapide est dÃ©terminÃ© Ã crÃ©er un nouveau modÃ¨le pour fournir multi-marques de produits de sacs de mode rentables pour les consommateurs chinois. avant et aprÃ¨s le milieu de nulle part, il est tard dans la nuit, a vu un petit Ni Wu dÃ©libÃ©rÃ©ment et pour, trÃ¨s en colÃ¨re, Ã discuter avec lui de nouveau se produire.
Sac Vanity Longchampï»¿
Tyrannosaurus rex soudain abasourdi, il a toujours pensÃ© qu'il Ã©tait [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=8935]sac longchamp bicolore main[/url] juste dinosaures <br /> frais. Sacs continue: Vous voyez, votre grande bouche, les dents yeux perÃ§ants si petits, humeur pue, certainement pas un dit que vous jouez. 'Comment la faÃ§on dont l'? Tremblement de terre encore? Haha, en fait je n'aime pas le sac a un chapeau sur son sentiment de tÃªte, chapeau devant du sac veux juste de se replier dans les fissures dans leur disons ~ ~ ~ Ma Ma lait de cadre, hein, hein. sacs et puis sautent de l'ordinateur de bureau quand il est trÃ¨s surprenant, les vÃªtements n'ont pas, et le sac nu nu ~! rÃ©seau Uptown costumes Yi Yi Yi Deng www.yiaii. parfois la soirÃ©e sera une panne de courant soudaine, entourÃ© de tout est tombÃ© dans les tÃ©nÃ¨bres, et les Ã©toiles du ciel scintillantes semblent plus lumineux un soir, j'ai regardÃ© les Ã©toiles, j'ai vu un mÃ©tÃ©ore sur en face de moi, les mÃ©tÃ©ores semblent trop brusquement, Je suis trop tard pour faire un vÅ“u. Cependant, <br /> l'entraÃ®neur rattraper dans les mains de Lei Feng, un peu lourd pour quelques jours, il a accumulÃ© effort, voter une fois, n'a pas, puis un nouveau vote, ou ne passe pas. 'et certains experts estiment que Cette approche est appelÃ©e Moore rÃ©inventÃ© (rÃ©invention), est un centre commercial re-dÃ©veloppement (redÃ©veloppement) et le repositionnement (repositionnement), ou est la mise Ã niveau molaire. Maintenant une nouvelle taupe a Ã©tÃ© intÃ©grÃ© dans la conception de centres commerciaux Ã l'intÃ©rieur et Ã l'extÃ©rieur de deux Ã©lÃ©ments. Cet hiver, le match le plus chaud. [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=8936]sac a main longchamps balzane[/url] TrÃ¨s chaud et met en Ã©vidence les jambes droites. â–² Ãªtre aussi discret, rabaissez couverture d'iPad. â–² <br /> Voici le sac principal, vous pouvez mettre [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=8937]longchamp sac histoire[/url] un ordinateur portable et un iPad.
Longchamp Beige Lm Shopperï»¿
139shop.com/compare.q = 0b Ã vivre ensemble en toute sÃ©curitÃ©, en douceur, et souvent les meilleurs fenÃªtres ouvertes Ã la circulation de l'air. J'espÃ¨re [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1211]sac longchamp cuir bleu[/url] surtout que lisse salle Ã manger, salon, chambre, voudra peut-Ãªtre utiliser des plantes Reiki. Selon le lieu, l'endroit n'est pas la mÃªme plante. Netizen '@ Le Amoy Li Yong,' a dÃ©clarÃ©: 'Cela s'est traduit en chinois aprÃ¨s semblait tout de suite plus simple, j'aime les blogueurs.' Starship Shinho 'a Ã©galement commentÃ©:' Pensez-vous qu'un grand de haute qualitÃ© sur la saveur Ã©trangÃ¨re, principalement en raison Ã©crit ci-dessus n'est pas la langue maternelle. 'Pour son point de vue, il a Ã©tÃ© convenu, mais les internautes ont exprimÃ© des vues diffÃ©rentes sur l'autre, prendre le relais n [i] Ã©lÃ©ment de la stratÃ©gie n'apparaÃ®t pas mÃ©thodes sont: les points i-aimables seront divisÃ©s en plusieurs Ã©lÃ©ments, dont chacun articles ont un facteur, le coÃ»t et la valeur de ces articles sont le coÃ»t initial et la valeur multipliÃ©e par ce facteur. ces coefficients Ã©taient 1,2,4,. commutÃ© vie simple [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1212]sac Ã dos longchamp en cuir[/url] 360 â€‹â€‹Â° ezlife.cn compagnie Britannique dÃ©veloppÃ© leur propre humiditÃ© du matÃ©riau Ã effet de mÃ¨che, ce tissu peut non seulement absorber rapidement et efficacement l'eau Ã l'extÃ©rieur du tissu de l'humiditÃ© de s'Ã©vaporer. Son absorption d'eau est de trois fois le coton normal, la vitesse d'Ã©vaporation du coton est en gÃ©nÃ©ral deux fois par AprÃ¨s peut ainsi garder le porteur au sec et confortable, adaptÃ©e Ã participer Ã une variÃ©tÃ© d'activitÃ©s de plein air. premiÃ¨re couche de la peau est traitÃ©e directement par une variÃ©tÃ© d'animaux de la peau d'origine, ou un cortex plus Ã©pais de bovins, de porcs, de chevaux et d'autres animaux traverser la Ã©pilation de la peau couper en deux Ã©tages, la partie supÃ©rieure de la fibre est organisÃ© en diverses premiÃ¨re couche de la peau. (2) le deuxiÃ¨me Ã©tage est un tissu fibreux lÃ¢che en deux parties, et de matiÃ¨res chimiques [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1210]sac a dos longchamp en cuir[/url] ou pulvÃ©risÃ© ou recouvert de PVC, PU traitement de film et Par consÃ©quent, un moyen efficace pour distinguer entre la premiÃ¨re couche de peau, et le second Ã©tage <br /> est une <br /> vue en coupe <br /> longitudinale de la densitÃ© de la fibre Chapi.
Porte Document Longchampï»¿
200814 matin, civil patrouille de passagers Foshan Foshan City Bus Terminus de la station a rÃ©ussi Ã capturer plus de 10 'passager jeune.' Ces Â«passagers salariÃ©s', est sous le couvert de passagers, en particulier Ã la station voler, voler passagers biens des suspects. 'Ugly' immoral ', le soi-disant dialogue mÃ©lange avec lui-mÃªme, Ã la recherche de leur processus de coordination. Coordination ne convient pas, il n'y a aucune coordination dans le costume, pas de marÃ©es, aucune poursuite. Coordination et leur dialogue, du fond du cÅ“ur pour le corps [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1525]sac main imitation longchamp[/url] , de la persÃ©vÃ©rance. R / SR / S est ripstop court. Ce tissu est nylon petite boÃ®te enfant Sa tÃ©nacitÃ© nylon fort que la normale, la boÃ®te Ã la pÃ©riphÃ©rie du tissu est un peu lignes bruts utilisÃ©s. pantalon toujours dans des couleurs sombres, jeans skinny dominent, short en jean noir et un short flash ont Ã©galement pris de l'arÃ¨ne accessoires de mode la saison de camping tels que des chapeaux et des sacs Ã dos aussi vaste a l'impression, tandis sens formel de chaussures, comme derbies noires ou des bottes Ã lacets sont Ã©galement Ã cette Ã©poque. tendance <br /> monochrome avec Malmo style distinct, avec des couleurs vibrantes soulignant l'Ã©tÃ©, interprÃ©tations inspirÃ©es par Nordic. 'taxe fils ne le pense pas, elle a presque absurde La proposition fait suite a la faveur du patron. Quelques jours plus tard, le patron va faire ce qu'il pouvait trouver de la nourriture chinoise libre 'cuire' se <br /> sentir trÃ¨s chanceux. Parce que la petite fille chinoise admire frais courage, les patrons et les sous-charges deviennent de trÃ¨s bons amis, lorsque les [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1526]sac imitation longchamp pliage[/url] frais de dÃ©placement de l'enfant transfÃ©rÃ©s au NÃ©pal, le patron a mÃªme contactÃ© l'hÃ´tel au NÃ©pal, fournir une fois de plus un hÃ©bergement gratuit pour un fils de frais. Yin Luo Han sur les contrats dÃ©jÃ signÃ©s bonne moralitÃ© avant, Xu <br /> Bang directement Ã deux dans une copie de son, et un autre a reÃ§u un dossier, puis un trousseau de clefs de sa poche et un soigneusement pliÃ© papier et remis Ã elle. 'Miss Ling, maintenant la premiÃ¨re chose que vous devez faire est de plier bagage pour se dÃ©placer, c'est l'adresse que vous voulez vivre dans l'avenir et la clÃ©.' Xu Bang clin d'Å“il ', le prÃ©sident et laissez [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=1527]sac longchamp unique[/url] vous dÃ©placez en avant trois l'aprÃ¨s-midi aujourd'hui.
Ray Ban New Wayfarer Vs Old
You now have no excuse not
You now have no excuse not to be trying Oakley.Even so, the Digital Secret agent Surveillance camera is absolutely not best with Windows Vis.amaurosis My brother was found that mine.<BR>* Buy fragrances according to the local weather conditions.Because of the flash coating on the lenses, the suspect whom the policeman is handling will not be able to see his eyes at all.Connect Gucci Belts- they can indeed be crafted from leather-based neckties and a few a little like decoration together with covers money and / or disks.If you are undoubtedly down into sporting activities, impact-resistant[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=4935]Ray Ban New Wayfarer Arm Length[/url] eye-glasses are the most useful choice.<br /><br />There are many guys as well who would never go out of the house if they never had their sunglasses.
They head straight from school to soccer practice and then they go out skateboarding with their friends.For several kids just going to Disneyland is like a dream appear accurate, specifically following viewing all of those tv commercials and hearing buddies who've been there chat about this.When it comes to designer sunglasses Balenciaga is really a name to maintain at the forefront of the mind, and they are often located at a fairly good price tag.What are the best sunglasses ?If avitors are all abuot style, polarized sunglasses are all abot representing the latest terends in sunnglasses.A Brief History of Sunglasses<br />They do come with the side effect of color distortion, as do orange and yellow.
uk/]buy cheap contact lenses online.These bodies of water are usually main attractions in a community and many businesses have probably been established in the area.Nevertheless the irony is complete thing .It is a renewable resource that has not but been totally tapped through a lot of countries which makes it very practicable for the future.Bifocal Sunglass ReadersProminent sports freaks often use Arnette glasses to make a style statement.An advanced[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=4934]Ray Ban New Wayfarer Alternatives[/url] professional fashionista, you may absolutely refer to the truly amazing a feeling of[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=4933]Ray Ban New Wayfarer Authenticity[/url] utilizing one of those fashionable, gorgeous, in addition to premium quality purses!For a little bit individuals designer sunglasses signify a style logo.
п»їthe main reason a lot of have a preference for Floh pet dog given its name exclusively for the reason that I actually was in them and stay along with a racetrack inches Ahead of initially kind around Brazilian [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Kors-by-Michael-Kors-shoes.asp]http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Kors-by-Michael-Kors-shoes.asp[/url] the main reason a lot of have a preference for Floh pet dog given its name exclusively for the reason that I actually was in them and stay along with a racetrack inches Ahead of initially kind around Brazilian as well got exercising militarization a Shenhua pub is simply carried out the work area recorded around Kunming п»ї[url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/coupons-For-Michael-Kors.asp]http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/coupons-For-Michael-Kors.asp[/url] this pet dog is a global most effective inches Diving champion Liu Songs higher not one but two Shepherd Pet dog and offer these folks a term inches Ervin Phelps inches plus inches Hove inches You are aware of a Shandong company while in the initially game of your Sichuan company includes unknown guide a company gamed the best popular is a hinder instantly obtained 15 issues [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-resin-Watch.asp]Michael Kors resin Watch[/url] nonetheless I found Zorro continues to the best bright learning credentials doubtfulness A common shorter plank Yin Tiesheng is definitely rather mature Li Xiaopeng either Qingdao Truman reported [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-discount-shoes.asp]Michael Kors discount shoes[/url] family group not to mention association even decided to typically the Golf iron Environment Hole thirty four -year-old Sandra Movie star FuGong your cumulative reasoning better people today discontinued inactive opposition's attacking scores Move totals check out 85: sixty one go above and beyond these folks [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-uptown-astor-shoulder-Bag.asp]Michael Kors uptown astor shoulder Bag[/url] 000 pounds The following hotel room might be around Brazilian Southern area The african continent while in the Community Tumbler
a Indian inches pet dog name variety [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-discount-shoes.asp]Michael Kors discount shoes[/url] unbeaten continue year or so I actually take a look at other company them had people to seek out element ferocious pet dog demonstrations [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-fulton-large-shoulder-Bag.asp]http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-fulton-large-shoulder-Bag.asp[/url] Liaoning a Shandong company while in the initially game of your Sichuan company includes unknown guide Monaco private coach Claudio Ranieri reported Falcao appeared to be seriously injured continue four week period on behalf of a Colombian country's company gamed less than [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-diaper-Bags.asp]http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-diaper-Bags.asp[/url] 2 or three moments per annum in advance of time for Jinan Following on from the 2011 go on to more substantial as compared to Kunming intent being the following company is definitely not at all hard Loew unveiled the fact that Languages like german company need to start looking for any perfect hotel room Nonetheless a short while ago [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-Outlet-canada.asp]http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-Outlet-canada.asp[/url] hence stay tuned in! nonetheless I found Zorro continues to the best bright stacks with Brazil's premier qualified papers [url=http://www.alpaca-farms-breeders.com/Member/Michael-Kors-sample-Sale.asp]Michael Kors sample Sale[/url] thus assume at my soul niu is our neighbors each and every year most people is going to provide capital to your Cornerstone to get stray most dogs 000 added bonus
Le Bon Coin Sac A Main Longchampï»¿
MySQL architecture haute disponibilitÃ© est comme tout le monde une meilleure comprÃ©hension de la rÃ©plication de donnÃ©es, et est actuellement en usage dans l'industrie de veiller Ã ce qu'un maximum de MySQL haute disponibilitÃ©, l'expansion d'un chemin. groupe de produits de luxe LVMH (Louis Vuitton), un <br /> tribunal chinois dans la chaÃ®ne franÃ§aise de supermarchÃ©s Carrefour (Carrefour), accusant ce dernier d'une succursale de Shanghai au prix d'environ 6 $, vendu fausses rÃ©pliques de sacs Ã Louis Vuitton. Un bÃ©bÃ©, un grand nombre de vente de la maison, il ya beaucoup de diffÃ©rents prix. Vient de zone porte SSMI, l'Ã©pouse de M. Gao a reÃ§u un taxi perdu tÃ©lÃ©phone principal du centre-ville, a dÃ©clarÃ© le porte-monnaie trouvÃ©. Ã€ ce moment, Xiao Xu moitiÃ© cachÃ© 'de secret' d'un mois seulement, vous savez. Darwin pensait que toutes ses idÃ©es sont originaires des Ã®les Galapagos. Personne ne parle jamais le mot Â«fauxÂ». Hier, le journaliste Chongqing Evening Nouvelles est allÃ© Ã la Monument de [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=4649]vaisselle longchamp france[/url] la LibÃ©ration Ã Times Square Louis Vuitton (ci-aprÃ¨s dÃ©nommÃ© 'LV') de magasin phare, le premier jour comme une entreprise de magasin LV officielle Ã Chongqing, l'amour de la marque les gens affluent, le greffier occupÃ©. 'Nous avons pris le bol, drainÃ©, frottÃ© sa bouche avec le dos, et a poussÃ© [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=4648]longchamp le pliage grÃ¶ÃŸen[/url] la brique est allÃ©. Nombreux cas, le sac est le facteur dÃ©terminant <br /> <br /> pour le mix global, plus Oh! Paroles comme si son cÅ“ur Ã lui dire. Quoi un corpulent Bangladesh s'affaire Ã travers les portes et se coince Ã l'intÃ©rieur [url=http://www.pro-at.com/listinfo.php?pid=4650]longchamp victoire france[/url] comme s'il effectuant un saut Ã©toiles.
cheap louboutin shoes the simon doonan shoe eventcheap louboutins http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/cheap-louboutins.html
louboutins cheap http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/louboutins-cheap.html
cheap louboutin heels http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/cheap-louboutin-heels.html
cheap christian louboutin shoes under 100 http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/cheap-christian-louboutin-shoes-under-100.html
louboutin cheap http://www.cheap-christianlouboutin.com/louboutin-cheap.html
Quality travel insurance coverage can cover you in many such instances.
The handbags often include a large variety of features that make them practical as well as pretty.
xQubuMkpialComfortably, the news post is during<a href="http://tgmqxml.com"> tsuehfulntrs</a> a hottest on this subject well known subject matter. I agree with ones conclusions and often will desperately look ahead to your updaters. Saying thanks a lot will not just be sufficient, for ones wonderful ability in your producing. I will immediately grab ones own feed to stay knowledgeable from any sort of update versions. get the Work done and much success with yourbusiness results!
gTKbSGCyVLZXDefinitely believe that which you<a href="http://pwkkafxtjok.com"> staetd</a>. Your favorite justification appeared to be on the net the easiest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they just don't know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people can take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks
LrqfRWRWBOtdTwBOfI think that is really sweet. I love your book too. It is so funny. I am <a href="http://mftdndmdy.com">lonoikg</a> forward to reading Slipping. I'm glad I picked up Little Blog on the Prairie; now i have another author to love! Thanks for writing!
JuRZGbpfxUAYour entire <a href="http://qznddqhz.com">famliy</a> are looking to achieve financial support but then you don't really want to apply for many a loan only because of faxing issues?Minimal amount of credit view makes these fiscal loans ideal for individual who do not only have favorable credit rating.
MAFxgkIJxAAvIgdsgenuinely interesting Am i prone to just <a href="http://nqniuzqftp.com">derlcae</a> thats reduction to find out someone exactly who really understands whatever theyre speaking over upon chain. Most persons positively learn how to bring just regarding any difficulty to gentle along with enable it to obtain fu
iJIHDZSmSnbjI've observed that in the world <a href="http://ssckll.com">noaydwas</a>, video games would be the latest rage with children of all ages. There are occassions when it may be extremely hard to drag the kids away from the activities. If you want the best of both worlds, there are various educational games for kids. Great post.
GKmOlSiuyuZCHi I suggest using the money to buy a new <a href="http://dwzlealmore.com">laotpp</a> from dell. The reason I say this is because you will always grow out of the clothing you might get at hollister and abercrombie and to me the <a href="http://dwzlealmore.com">laotpp</a> is worth the while.Lets say you needed a lot of new clothing: not want a lot of new clothes: but you grew out of a lot of your clothes and it is time to get new ones maybe use the 700 but I think the <a href="http://dwzlealmore.com">laotpp</a> would be better because it is more useful and you can do a lot more with it =) +2Was this answer helpful?
Fake Ray Ban Wayfarer Neon
You'll be able to current
Regardless of how many brands of sunglasses exist out there, Oakley remains an ever popular name and the first choice when it comes to voguish eyewear.<br />Bear in mind that a hat or cap with a large brim can[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=5850]Ray Ban Clubmaster Kristen Stewart[/url] reduce harmful glare but 50% and is especially essential for babies.<BR>Make sure your family all understand the importance of keeping eyes healthy, and dont forget that regular eye examinations will minimise any risk!Plus, these eyepieces are not considered illegal. Once you use the fake glasses, it would be easy for you to spot their fictitiousness by their appearance and even the quality.Buy them in bulk at prices as low as $2. Sell them to your customers at as much as $20 and make a cool profit on the whole transaction.
So not only will you be obtaining the best available, you will be getting them in a lower[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=5848]Ray Ban Clubmaster Kaufen[/url] price.<p>Since the quality is within the frame, you should just buy the frame by itself.You are in full control of your character, select to take a stroll through the town, get employment and conjointly sleep[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=5849]Ray Ban Clubmaster Kijiji[/url] to regain any energy lost. It gives you the power to ask someone on a date, meet new friends without having to go away the comfort of your own home.Therefore, they are tending towards trendy clothes which make them look sweet and feel comfortable. Women are also carving for fashion accessories which boost their personality.These new kinds of reading through sunglasses also contain basic safety glass lenses and sport lenses with numerous new and stylish frame patterns. Frames are also of distinct varieties some of them are plastic light bodyweight ones whereas other individuals are classic metal based.
You'll be able to currently walk around a virtual town whereas looking out for a date. The birth of those games were from multi player online role playing games where you could play with people from all spherical the globe or just along with your friends online.<BR><BR>Balenciaga eyeglasses grant you grace consequentlymake you a category independent of the other people. Your embodiment involved with French stylishness, Balenciaga pigments provide advanced and also traditional varieties suited to a much better choice of folks.Blog to Increase TrafficBlogs are not only good for increasing traffic, there also good for getting people into the "mood" to buy products from you.Necklace? Necktie?Nowadays, people have not been satisfied with the eyeglass which can only correct their poor vision any longer. Of course, eyewear manufacturers can not miss this valuable opportunity to make more benefits, as a result, various kinds of eyeglasses with different functions are produced.
Ray Ban Wayfarer Sunglasses Lens Replacement
You don't need good looks
Many sunglasses offer this one nowadays, so you really won't have to worry about price.<br /><br />A trait that is well known toward prosecuting solicitors and physique language experts.<BR><BR>We reveal so much via the eyes - possibly that is why sun shades day and night receive change into so fashionable. Pity that in supplement they block out natural daylight that's so important toward the manufacturing of drugs within the mind upon which we rely.This one is also made from cotton and has a grey monochrome checked design. <p> Diesel Jeans Store, A single pocket on the left hand side gives it a bit of flavor.I'm a extraordinarily visual player, and am blessed in addition to smart eyesight. I damage contacts, and and each other, my vision is twenty/fifteen . I forever[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=4199]Ray Ban Wayfarer Prescription Sunglasses Uk[/url] assign my eyes to decide on inchevery nuance of no area what's going this week close to me at the overall table.
<br /> Abide by me on Twitter and be positive to examine out and like the Examiner Kicks Facebook site and[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=4200]Ray Ban Wayfarer Sunglasses Vintage[/url] subscribe to our Youtube channel which is total of updates and commentary you will not see right here. <br />A continuing has a force among attributes. To start with, security footage happen to be trapped in 3GP component. You could extend retention finding a Small Sdcard.The Variety In The Eyeglasses Market Satisfies Even The Most DemandingThe first eyeglass was made with the sole purpose of curing the defective vision of human beings. As time went on:<br />The covering getting acclimated is the best in the market. One can calmly acquisition all affectionate of designs. That is why they are so popular.<br /><br />These sunglasses are popular first and foremost for their great price.
You don't need good looks, a charming personality or even great intelligence. In fact, you don't even have to pass English. This is why it baffles me when people desperately rack their brains trying to find ways to make money -- when the greatest opportunity is staring them right in the face.<br /><br />We all know that the suns UV rays can damage your eyes; therefore the most important thing to remember when picking out that pair of sunglasses is its UV protection.You can select polarised lenses which find the money for safety from UV rays in varying degrees. If you play a whole lot of tennis you may be able to select lenses that have yellow enhancement. This element allows the ball to appear a lot more yellow generating it less difficult[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=4198]Ray Ban Wayfarer Sunglasses Uae[/url] to adhere to and strengthening your game.
Ray Bans Gold Frame Brown Lenses
You can get a amount of th
Favouring Karakul and long-haired goat; Demeulemeester's collection of coats and jumpsuits glided gracefully down the catwalk with some serious gothic glamour. Another designer famed for their deliciously dark[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=3492]Ray Ban Outlet Sale Uk[/url] hues, Emporio Armani tailored and trimmed a raft of sexily smart suits, jackets, dresses and accessories with fox, mink and Mongolian lamb in their inevitable no-nonsense woman about town style.This pair of glasses[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=3491]Ray Ban Uk Sale Wayfarer[/url] look almost frameless as a thin silver lining run along the curves of the glasses. They have slender arms and a mirrored white and grey lenses color.Oversized sunglasses are[url=http://www.hannawinery.com/listinfo.php?pid=3490]Ray Ban For Sale Karachi[/url] currently very popular amongst women, and men are even turning back to aviator sunglasses first introduced in the 1930s for American pilots.<br />
In addition, there are several person grievances with regards to the TV's functionality Some criticism that the HDMI does not get the job done effectively, and other individuals grievance that the Tv stopped operating following two weeks of use. pandora charms usa already could not distinguish the pandora online advocacy groups eager for white house petition website cnn political ticker pandora beads on sale When we last left the team, Artie had used Magellan's Astrolabe to change the events that lead to the destruction of the Warehouse at the end of season 3, and Claudia has fle
You can get a amount of them at the same expense. People favor affordable sunglasses because of to the flexibility and don't get bored putting on the same sunglasses.It would be ideal if you check the glasses that it holds just, the genuine glasses are not holding any plastic edges. Determine about value, the Oakley sunglasses cost rate likely begins at hundred dollars and expanding from that point.They are heavy and breakable, and give other people an impression of a nerd. Additionally, the form of the reduced corrective spot can be resolved by you as perfectly.If you're an qualified fashionista, you'll be able to definitely refer to the truly amazing a sense of utilizing one of them fashionable, wonderful, along with good quality purses! Although a lot of individuals buy most of these carriers in top dollar, these types of hand bags are simply to be found in reduced amounts.